So, I'll probably do a weekly Lost post. Today's ep wasn't one of my favourites, let's just say that. And not because, like what other people are saying, that it's somehow filler or that the alternate reality's story was inconsequential or that nothing happened. I don't think any of those charges are at all appropriate. It actually has a lot of character type development, and the juxtaposition made for a nice pathos. I suspect most people had problems because it came directly after the mindfuck that was "LA X", which I think makes it an unfair comparison. This episode felt to me to be more of a lead-up episode, particular in the realm of character development. No, the results of the setup won't be seen next episode, but for later in the season, but it definitely sets up something that could potentially 'end' Kate's character-arc.
But discussing the character arcs isn't as fun as it is to discuss the mythology. And this ep didn't offer a whole lot, but what it did is truly interesting.
Let's assume that the use of the word "infected" by Lennon is not a red herring and actually referencing the infection of Rousseau, which they actually outright showed us last season. Even then we could sort of tell, when someone gets infected they are no longer themselves (ie, Robert trying to kill Rousseau), which follows along the lines of the spreading darkness to their hearts. Though I wonder if maybe Rousseau herself was infected, OR if she really did go batshit crazy from 16 years of solitutde.
So one has to wonder ... does one have to be dead to be claimed/infected? If so then that explains why Richard wanted his Others' bodies back in "LaFleur" and why they burnt Colleen's body back in season three. There were lots of speculation last year about whether the claimed were Smokey, since he took them into the declivity in the temple wall where this infection seemed to happen (and what kept Rousseau from getting claimed was because she didn't go down thanks to Jin). The refuting evidence was that Robert and the others could be killed by bullets, which made no sense since Smokey can only make apparitions (or so we thought...).
Though if it is Smokey who claims/infects people, why did he not do the same with Locke? Why make an apparition? Perhaps being claimed doesn't mean you become a puppet of Smokey, rather your darkness is unlocked or you lose your humanity ... but basically you just become a chaotic being (the human would be gone). Smokey, to further his agenda actually needs to manifest himself as someone.
So one must ask, what is with the tests they gave to Sayid?
The first test, the blowing of ash, seems pretty obvious ... They had to make sure that it wasn't MIB/Smokey who may've found a loophole. Since the ash had no reaction with him, we can conclude that it's not MIB. Though it should be interesting what would happen if someone tied Locke down and poured the ash on him...
The second test ... This is my own pet theory. I believe that the electrocution was fake, that is the wires weren't connected to the machine or that the machine was a fake that would generate the noise. Perhaps, those that are claimed no longer actually feel, they actually become zombies. So when Sayid reacted to getting electrocuted, it convinced Dogen that Sayid was faking (or actually believing he was electrocuted ... see below), since a normal human would not react and scream in pain to no stimulus.
As for the fire poker (third test) I have no answer. I'd like to think it was fake, though it'd be hard to fake pulling it out of a roaring fire. Who knows, maybe he wanted to see what would happened to a claimed who was actually hurt? Dunno, this is the hole in my theory.
I also believe the pill was a fourth test. Something to confirm things. Give poison to Sayid, who will willingly take it from Jack. If Sayid doesn't die then he is definitely a claimed person. And I say this so I can make the "he has to take it willingly" stuff make sense. To accommodate this, I'm going to suggest that the claimed are highly suggestible beings who lose all cognitive thought. If they think they ought to be feeling pain, they will 'create' that pain for themselves or at least scream out in pain. If they think they ought to die when they get shot in the head (ie, Robert) then they will die. But if they have no reason to think this, then they will be impervious to it.
It's a bit complicated and convoluted I grant, but I see no non-mystical reason why poison has to be taken willingly. Unless they just didn't want to be the ones to administer the poison themselves and wanted Jack to take the blame/guilt.
Also, the other big reveal. If Dogen is right and Claire was infected and claimed, then that means she also died, which many people were suspecting, when the mercenaries nuked her house in the DHARMA barracks back in season four, and when Miles kept looking at her funny. It would also be the reason why Claire would willingly abandon Aaron.
This also leads to the question ... who is Claiming them? I think we're being lead to believe it's MIB, which would make sense, since he killed the Rousseau team. But is claiming one of his functions? If so, how did his power get into the Temple?
Perhaps it is Jacob and his touch. Maybe the touches from the season 5 finale were acts of pre-emptive claiming for when they died, rather than to bring them to the Island was we all suspected. In fact, did he even revive Locke when he fell and broke his back?! Or did Jacob claim the body as his own and turned Locke into a 'zombie'? Does this bear any significance on MIB using Locke? Perhaps that's why Locke could walk when flight 815 crashed on the Island, he didn't actually heal so much as delude himself into having the ability and therefore gained the ability. Which would seem like when their heart is consumed by the darkness they start acting in the best interests of the Island in blind faith. Would also explain why Locke isn't so bitter in "LA X" ... maybe he never died and still retains humanity. (Oh, oh oh! Did all of our Losties die when 815 crashed and subsequently turned into the claimed? Thus the alternate realities show us how they are when not claimed?)
Maybe it's some third party, or the Island. Perhaps it's Christian?? Or is Christian himself someone who was claimed?
It would seem, with my theory, that the Claimed for all intents and purposes think they're still alive, and that their rational faculties and moral sensibilities are in-tact. They have their memories, do not know they are dead, and act like they normally do until the darkness consumes their heart. Then what? They start killing those they love? They are enacting the will of the Island or Jacob or MIB?
Can't wait for next week's episode. STOP READING IF YOU HAVEN'T SEEN THE PROMO FOR NEXT WEEK.
Those people who think Sawyer's gonna die from the promo are so stupid. Do they not see that MIB is also in that frame down the bottom? The 'falling' down the ladder is like an abseiling movement. Mark my words. See it happen next week. Also: am I the only one who sees a cave opening on that giant cliff?? Ties in with other major spoilers promo released just before "LA X" where they enter into a cave with scales and a black/white rock (and I think a Jacob ghost).